This week we read a chapter about service learning.
What is service learning? A more specific definition of service learning is a
research-based teaching method where guided or classroom learning is applied
through action that addresses an authentic community need in a process that
allows for youth participation and provides organized time for reflection on
the service experience and demonstration of acquired skills and knowledge
(Kaye, 2010). In other terms, service learning is a teaching method that allows
students to perform community service in order to learn knowledge and acquired
skills connected to the curricular objectives. Students then are involved in
planning and implementing service activities. As we have read in chapter 1,
these activities can range across all curriculum fields beginning from
kindergarten to post-secondary education, some examples are: putting together a
community canned food drive in health class to emphasize healthy eating for
kids, middle school social studies students doing research on their local
social service food bank agency and developing a plan to better supply and meet
the needs of the community, younger students working to plant vegetables in a
community garden, students developing a proposal for their school to reduce the
carbon footprint, and students helping the elderly (Kaye, 2010). From a
student’s point of view, they become engaged in the ecosystem and become more
diverse through the practice of citizenship. Regardless of students’ strengths
or weaknesses, service learning lets them be intellectually invested and
motivate them to learn in and out of the classroom. Therefore, service learning
allows students to carry on their learning and become fruitful. Service
learning differs from community service because it allows for student ownership
and reflection in an academic nature by relating to the curriculum to provide
emphasis on service activities. From a teacher’s point of view, it is important
to design a plan that identifies the need, considers the community and what
best works in your classroom, student participation in the entire process, researching
the underlying issue, the purpose of the content, and fulfilling academic
standards (Kaye, 2010).
Three different types of service:
1. Direct
service – is face-to-face interactions that directly involve the recipients.
Students in direct service learn about caring for others who are older or
younger than them, have different experiences, or working with refugees.
Students develop problem-solving skills by following a sequence from beginning
to end and seeing the big picture of a social justice issue (Kaye, 2010).
2. Indirect
service – are indirect activities where students do not see the recipients
however their actions benefit the environment or community as a whole (Kaye,
2010). Through indirect service students learn through cooperation by working
in teams. Some examples from the reading are donating books to a preschool
literacy program, stocking a food pantry, and donating clothes to families
living in shelters.
3. Advocacy
– creates awareness of or promotes action on an issue of public interest. This
type of learning must be authentic, meaning it must respond to genuine
community needs (Kwak, Shen, & Kavanaugh 2002). Through advocacy students
provide a voice for those who can’t speak for themselves. Examples of advocacy
activities are public speaking, promoting a town meeting, and writing letters.
Advocacy ensure student engagement in their community allowing them to
participate in civic citizenship and diversity sceneries.
4. Research
– involves students finding, gathering, and reporting on information in the
public interest (Kaye, 2010). Research-based service learning permits students
to gather information and make discriminating judgements. An examples of research-based
service learning is students gathering information to conduct a survey on water
or soil contamination.
After reading this chapter, I discovered that I would
want to know some things about my own community. I want to know about how to
make sure safety is optimal at schools and what to do about promoting a better
safety program in schools not just during “safety week” but throughout the
school year. The reason I bring this up is, I have been working with a
community in EPISD and parents are constantly complaining about the lack of EPISD
officers patrolling around their elementary and middle school. Also, parents
have witnessed adults drinking and doing drugs on the street corners by the
schools and using abandon homes in the neighborhood to distribute their drugs.
A proposal idea for me would be based on how to get the community involved and
provide better safety and health promotions. A concern I have is, what happens when service learning grows from mixed
motives and conflicting emotions between diverse populations? How can that
conflict be resolved between two or more individuals that do not agree with the
community?
Kaye, C. B. (2010). The complete
guide to service learning: Proven, practical ways to engage students in civic
responsibility, academic curriculum, & social action. Minneapolis, MN:
Free Spirit Publishing.
Kwak, C., Shen, J., & Kavanaugh,
A. (2002). An Overview of the Practice and Development of Service-Learning. Educational Horizons, 80(4), 190-194. Retrieved from
http://0-www.jstor.org.lib.utep.edu/stable/42927127
Hi Denise,
ReplyDeleteI like that you emphasize students’ involvement, it is important as you mention that they take part of the plan and implementation process.
I think this model is good to involve students in social service while they are learning. I think this type of learning process can be more significant for students precisely because they are involved in all the process, and they are continuously looking for improve their actions in the community.
I wonder what types of proposals you like to work with this method. Maybe as science teacher you can have different opportunities to solve problems. As you said, knowing a little more about our community can give us insights about the problems that can be used to create learning opportunities to involve students.
What do you think is the biggest issue to implement the method?
Denise, I feel you captured the essence of service learning and you convey the author’s definition as being a research-based teaching method involving either guided or classroom learning is applied into the actual community. I do believe that students through community service will acquire both knowledge and skill through the experience. It’s easily seen that service learning can cross multiple disciplines and involve elements which can range from mathematics as students work out actual logistics drawing a project or history and culture as students are involved in their local community. I found the project your involved in to be very important and wonder if you can think of a way that students take action to solve this problem?
ReplyDeleteHello Denise,
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed reading your summary! You did an remarkable job in identifying the elements as well as the stages of the service learning style of teaching students. Your proposal is quite interesting and intriguing as it does bring up an big issue in education concerning our students. Safety is always a concern of parents and teachers alike, as our students are always in harms way whenever they are faced with decision like peer pressures and drugs. I am with you that parents and the entire community would do a better job at putting an end to these obstacles than with just relying solely on law enforcement. Together we can accomplish more, and with this idea it could happen. How do you think a project of this magnitude can be pulled off at the district level? Who would need to be involved?
Hello Denise,
ReplyDeleteI like that you start by providing the full, verbose definition of service learning from the reading, and then immediately summarize it in a much more succinct and easy to understand way. Throughout your reflection you continue this excellent practice of defining a term or activity formally then explaining what it means in easily accessible language. A minor critique related to proof-reading, there are four major types of servicing learning in the chapter we read, but you say in a section heading there are three. You did, however, list all four. Interestingly, you and I both brought up the issue of safety in our reflections, albeit in different forms. To synergize the two, I would like to ask how would you ensure student safety during a service learning project to address community safety as you propose?
-SFM